Saturday, June 1, 2013

PE investors: recent off-shore tax developments 私募股权投资人:离岸税务最新动态_China Business Law Journal


PE investors: recent off-shore tax developments
China Business Law Journal

With the recent focus on Irish tax treatments and investigation into the tax profile of a well known high-tech corporation, reviewing tax structures has become a hot topic. Nobody wants to pay more taxes than is legally required. However, the line between tax avoidance and evasion remains slim.
Private equity investors frequently review tax planning when structuring a deal, and then move on to the real business of ensuring/monitoring asset performance, trusting external advisers to keep them updated on changes. However, this “build and forget” model may not be as sound as many private equity investors assume. When changes in tax enforcement patterns occur, legal ambiguity and conflict of interest may delay warnings.

For private equity investors into China, this issue needs to be reviewed in light of the State Administration of Taxation’s (SAT) recent issuance of its Opinion on Implementing the Dividends Provision Under the Tax Arrangement Between Mainland China and Hong Kong in Cases Involving Beneficial Ownership (Circular 165) and other pronouncements made in the past few years.
Treaty shopping in Hong Kong

Treaty Shopping is widespread and can be a legal tax mitigation method whereby a taxable investor reviews tax treaties/laws among jurisdictions to find favourable rates on taxable items such as withheld income or capital gains. For example, a parent corporation domiciled in a tax haven (TopCo) may own a corporation in a second country (OpCo). Any dividend from OpCo to HoldCo are subject to withholding tax in the operating jurisdiction at the normal rate for that jurisdiction, unless a tax treaty between the two jurisdictions provides otherwise. If a favourable tax treaty is not present, professional advisers often assist companies to mitigate their tax exposure by inserting a holding company from a favourable tax treaty jurisdiction into the structure.
The PRC has a variety of current tax treaties with various jurisdictions. One of the most popular is with Hong Kong, where tax rates on dividends are reduced from 10% (the applicable rate in the PRC) to 5% (a rate withheld prior to distribution to the Hong Kong shareholders). However, if the ultimate “beneficial owner” is determined to be outside of Hong Kong—making the Hong Kong entity effectively a shell—the treaty tax benefits are not available. 

Determining what constitutes a beneficial owner under PRC tax law becomes an important issue when structuring an offshore investment. These issues were first outlined in the SAT’s Notice Concerning the Meaning and Determination of ‘Beneficial Owner’ in Tax Treaties (Circular 601) and Announcement Concerning the Determination of Beneficial Owner Under Tax Treaties (Announcement 30). Circular 601 stipulates that only beneficial owners can receive the benefit of a tax treaty, generally outlines the definition of beneficial owner, and proposes seven factors that would negatively impact such a determination. Announcement 30 builds on that by clarifying that listed holding companies, are beneficial owners, that having a legitimate business purpose by itself was not enough (i.e. the structure cannot be designed just to avoid tax) and that the seven factors should be considered collectively in making an assessment on tax status.
Circular 165 seeks to clarify the definition of beneficial owner with specific reference to the terms of the Hong Kong tax treaty with the PRC, by detailing how to interpret several of the negative factors listed in Circular 601.

Regarding these factors, Circular 165 provides that:

  • when determining the applicability of the tax treaty to a Hong Kong entity, the local SAT bureau should review relevant materials regarding i) the entity’s profit distribution situation (e.g. does it distribute profits and to what degree are those prefixed) and (ii) degree of control by its non-Hong Kong parent company, all as evidenced by its articles of association, relevant agreements and other corporate documents;
  • investment companies with merely one project will not necessarily be disqualified from receiving the benefit of the tax treaty, but must be carefully reviewed in the context of the other factors;
  • the assets of the Hong Kong entity should be analysed in comparison to the income of the entity, and assets should not be considered registered capital;
  • the employees’ responsibilities and substance of work should be examined, rather than the number of staff; and
  • since Hong Kong employs a territorial system of taxation, and the PRC government has seen fit to enter into a tax treaty with Hong Kong, the fact that Hong Kong’s tax rate is low should not be the key factor.

Circular 165 also reiterates the language of Announcement 30 regarding it being a collective determination based on a review of all of the factors, with no one factor disqualifying the applicant.

Anti-treaty shopping measures

Circular 165 should be considered a shot across the bow of Hong Kong entities claiming beneficial ownership status of the PRC/Hong Kong tax treaty.  Circular 165 was issued after consultation with the Hong Kong tax authorities and after some SAT-conducted studies of the actual practices in Hong Kong. The PRC has issued various other “anti-treaty shopping” measures through statements regarding the enforcement of tax treaties and renegotiating existing tax treaties. 

Furthermore, private equity investors who avail themselves of the beneficial owner definition under a tax treaty should not assume that external accounting firms will provide the necessary oversight and warning. For auditors, there may be a conflict of interest. After setting up or signing off on a structure, changes in interpretation or enforcement might lead to difficult discussions regarding restructuring or booking more withholding. Also, as an application for treatment as a beneficial owner under a tax treaty must be filed each time a dividend is issued, and the continued applicability of the treatment re-examined, there is a chance that, after such a reinterpretation or change of enforcement, the SAT will determine that the entity is disqualified. In such cases, authorities have the ability to retroactively seek taxes not previously paid on dividends that were previously allowed, and assess interest penalties on such ‘late’ payments.

Simon Luk is a partner and chairman of Asia practice at Winston & Strawn in Hong Kong. He can be contacted on +852 2292 2000 or by email at sluk@winston.com

Mark Jacobsen is a registered foreign lawyer (California, USA) at Winston & Strawn in Hong Kong. He can be contacted on +852 2292 2000 or by email at mjacobsen@winston.com

 

私募股权投资人:离岸税务最新动态


 
私募股权(PE)投资人在设计交易结构时会经常审核评估税务筹划方案,之后再开始真正的商业事务——确保/监控资产运营状况,并依赖外部顾问随时报告资产变化情况。然而,这种“确立后即放在一边不闻不问”的模式,可能并不像很多PE投资人设想的那样可靠。当税务执法模式发生改变时,人们可能会因法律自身规定的模糊性和利益冲突得不到及时地警示。

对于来中国投资的PE投资人来说,考虑这个问题时要参考《国家税务总局关于湖北等省市国家税务局执行内地与香港税收安排股息条款涉及受益所有人案例的处理意见》(税总函〔2013年〕165号处理意见)及最近几年颁布的其他公告。
 

香港套用税收协定的情况

套用税收协定(Treaty Shopping)的做法广泛存在,其可以作为一种合法减轻税负的手段:投资人纳税人可以查阅相关法域之间签订的税收协定/法律,从中找出对自己有利的所得税或资本利得税等税目的税率,以合法降低税负。例如,住所地在一个“纳税天堂”的母公司(控股公司)可能拥有住所地在其他国家的一个公司(子公司)的所有权。子公司派发给控股公司的所有股息都必须按照子公司运营地所属法域规定的正常税率缴纳预提税,除非两法域间的税收协定另有规定。如果两法域间不存在有利的税收协定,为帮助公司降低税收风险,专业咨询顾问通常会在公司结构中加入一级控股公司结构,且该控股公司的所属法域与相关法域签订有有利的税收协定。

 
中国内地与多个法域签有有效的税收协定,其中最常见的是与香港特区签订的税收协定。根据该协定,股息的税率从中国内地当前适用的10%降至5%(派发给香港股东之前的代扣税率)。然而,如果最终受益所有人被认定不在香港的,即香港公司其实是壳公司的,则不得享受税收协定规定的优惠待遇。
 

在设计离岸投资交易结构时,确定怎样才构成中国内地税法定义的“受益所有人”成为一个重要问题。这一问题最先在《国家税务总局关于如何理解和认定税收协定中“受益所有人”的通知》(国税函〔2009〕601号通知)和《国家税务总局关于认定税收协定中“受益所有人”的公告》(国家税务总局公告2012年第30号公告)中有所阐述。国税函〔2009〕601号通知规定了只有“受益所有人”才能享受税收协定的待遇,并给出了“受益所有人”的大致定义,和提出了7项不利于申请人“受益所有人”身份认定的因素。国家税务总局公告2012年第30号公告在该通知的基础上进一步澄清:上市控股公司本身具有合法的商业目的还不足以被认定为“受益所有人”,即该结构的设计不得纯粹为了避税;以及在评估纳税身份时,应综合考虑国税函〔2009〕601号通知规定的7项因素。

税总函〔2013年〕165号处理意见详细解释了国税函〔2009〕601号通知列出的几项不利因素,进一步明确了“受益所有人”的定义,并具体提到了香港与内地的税收协定的规定。

税总函〔2013年〕165号处理意见对该等因素的规定如下:
 
·         在确定税收协定是否适用于香港实体时,地方国税局应审查以下相关材料:(i) 该实体的利润分配情形 (比如是否分配利润,以及预提比重等)以及(ii)其非香港居民母公司对其的控制程度,上述情况的证明文件包括企业章程、相关合同和其他公司文件;

·         为单个项目所设立的投资公司并不必然没有资格享受税收协定的优惠待遇,但必须结合其他因素谨慎审查;

·         应分析香港实体的资产与其所得数额是否匹配,不应将“资产”等同于注册资本;

·         应当着重分析和审查人员的职责与工作实质,而不得仅依靠人员数量做出判断;及

·         由于香港实行的是来源地征税原则,且内地政府认为与香港特区达成税收协定是适当的,因此香港税率低这一事实不应作为不利于受益所有人身份判定的关键因素。
 
税总函〔2013年〕165号处理意见还重申了国家税务总局公告2012年第30号公告关于对所有因素综合考量作出决定的规定,不得仅凭一项因素判定申请人无资格享受税收协定的优惠待遇。

反协定套用办法

对于申请内地/香港税收协定“受益所有人”身份的香港实体而言,税总函〔2013年〕165号处理意见应被看作一个示警。在税总函〔2013年〕165号处理意见颁布之前,国税局与香港税务机关进行过磋商,并对香港的实际操作情况也进行了一些调研。内地还通过发表税收协定执法情况声明,以及重启现有税收协定的谈判,颁布了多个其他反协定套用办法。

此外,根据税收协定获得“受益所有人”身份的PE投资人不应当假定外部会计师事务所能够为其提供必要的监督与警示。审计师与此可能会有利益冲突。在确立或完成公司结构设计后,司法解释或执法情况发生变化的,可能会引发结构重组或者扣税更多的艰难谈判。还有,因为在每一次派发股息时都必须重新根据税收协定提出“受益所有人”身份认定申请,是否继续享受优惠待遇也要重新进行审查,因此在法律被重新解释或执法活动发生变化之后,国税总局有可能会做出不认定“受益所有人”身份的决定。在这种情况下,税务机关可以补征税款,并加收滞纳金。

陆志明律师是美国温斯顿律师事务所香港分所的合伙人及亚洲业务主席。他的联系电话:+852 2292 2000;电邮:sluk@winston.com。

Mark Jacobsen(马克杰)律师是美国温斯顿律师事务所香港分所的注册外国律师(美国加州)。他的联系电话:+852 2292 2000;电邮:mjacobsen@winston.com。

 

 

 

Saturday, May 4, 2013

Practical issues on Hong Kong’s inside information disclosure (有关香港内幕消息披露制度的一些实用问题) _China Business Law Journal


Practical issues on Hong Kong’s inside information disclosure

China Business Law Journal

 
Following the implementation of Hong Kong’s new statutory regime on inside information disclosure on 1 January 2013, the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) observed an increase of over 40% of corporate announcements on inside information in the first three months of 2013, as compared to the same quarter of 2012. The SFC recently released certain guidelines in the form of frequently asked questions (FAQs) to advise Hong Kong-listed issuers on the application of the provisions of Part XIVA of the Securities and Futures Ordinance (SFO) and the SFC Guidelines on Disclosure of Inside Information. 
 
Listed issuers’ and officers’ duties

The SFO expands and codifies the existing obligations of disclosure of price sensitive information by Hong Kong-listed issuers under the listing rules of Hong Kong’s Stock Exchange. Subject to the applicability of “safe harbours” in the SFO, listed issuers are statutorily required to disclose to the public any inside information that has come to their knowledge as soon as reasonably practicable. A listed issuer will be regarded to have knowledge of the inside information if:
 
(a)             one or more of its officers knows or ought reasonably to have known that information in the course of performing functions as officers of the issuer; and

(b)            a reasonable person, acting as an officer of the corporation, would consider that the information is inside information in relation to the issuer.
 
The meaning of “officer” is broadly construed. It encompasses an issuer’s directors, company secretary and managers. A person may be regarded as a manager if he is under the immediate authority of the board and is in charge of management responsibility affecting the whole, or a substantial part, of the issuer. 

The SFC considers that it is the officers who are ultimately responsible for the compliance of the issuer’s disclosure obligations. The SFO requires every officer to take all reasonable measures from time to time to ensure that proper safeguards exist to prevent a breach of the disclosure requirement. An officer would have personal liability under the SFO if the issuer fails to make due disclosures, and it is his intentional, reckless or negligent conduct that resulted in the issuer’s breach. Non-executive directors, who are usually not involved in the day-to-day operations of the issuer, may be liable if the board as a whole fails to establish or monitor key internal control procedures to ensure the issuer’s due compliance with the disclosure requirements.
 
What is inside information?
 
The SFO defines inside information to mean, in relation to a listed issuer, specific information that is related to (a) the issuer, (b) its shareholder or officer, or (c) its securities or their derivatives, and which is not generally known to the persons who are accustomed or would be likely to deal in the listed securities of the issuer, but would if generally known to them be likely to materially affect the price of the listed securities.  

Whether any particular information will constitute inside information is dependent on its own facts and circumstances. Information that is incomplete and yet capable of allowing a matter or an event to be identified, and its nature to be coherently described and understood, may constitute specific information. The same applies even if a contemplated transaction is only at the stage of preliminary negotiation, if such transaction is more than a vague hope or wishful thinking.

An issuer should not take it for granted that any information which has been reported in the media or analysts’ reports will be regarded as generally known. It should consider how widely the information has been and will be disseminated in the market, and whether the disseminated information is accurate and complete. If the information known to the market is not readily available to retail investors, or is incomplete or inaccurate, such information cannot be regarded as generally known.

The issuer should further assess whether the information is likely to materially affect the market price of its listed securities. The assessment will depend on various factors, such as the nature and size of the issuer, the subject matter of the information, and market conditions. 

Manner and timing of disclosure

An issuer must immediately take all necessary steps to disclose any inside information through the electronic publication system of Hong Kong’s stock exchange – by way of corporate announcements – unless the information falls within the “safe harbours” under section 307D of the SFO. Before full disclosure is made, the issuer should ensure that the information is kept strictly confidential. If confidentiality cannot be maintained, it should consider applying for a suspension of trading in its securities until disclosure can be made. 

Practical concerns in making announcements

In the FAQs, the SFC makes it clear that an issuer should not use the heading of “voluntary announcement” in making inside information disclosures. Rather, it is expected to adopt a meaningful heading for the announcement, which accurately reflects the substance of the information concerned. Otherwise, the issuer will risk non-compliance with the SFO.

The inside information in the announcements should be factual, clear and expressed in a balanced and objective manner. Key messages should be clearly visible and presented in a readily understandable manner. Sufficient quantitative information that has come to the knowledge of the listed issuer should be included to ensure that the announcement is not false or misleading.
 

Simon Luk is a partner and the chairman of Asia practice at Winston & Strawn in Hong Kong. He can be contacted on +852 2292 2222 or by email at sluk@winston.com

 
Fiona Tang is a solicitor at Winston & Strawn in Hong Kong. She can be contacted on +852 2292 2218 or by email at ftang@winston.com

 

有关香港内幕消息披露制度的一些实用问题

香港有关内幕消息披露的新法定制度于2013年1月1日实施后,香港证券及期货事务监察委员会(证监会)观察到,就2013年第一季度而言,公司的内幕消息公告与2012年同期相比增长超过40%。证监会最近以“常见问题解答”(FAQs)的形式就《证券及期货条例》第XIVA部有关条款及证监会发布的《内幕消息披露指引》向香港上市公司提供了一些指引。

上市公司及其高级人员的职责
 
《证券及期货条例》对香港联合交易所的上市规则下现有的香港上市发行人股价敏感资料披露义务作了扩展并纳入法例。除非《证券及期货条例》中“安全港”规则能够适用,法例要求上市公司在合理地切实可行的范围内尽快向公众披露上市公司已知的任何内幕信息。下列情形将被视为上市公司已知内幕消息:
 
(a)公司的一名或多名高级人员在履行其分内职能的过程中,知道或理应知道该等信息;及

(b)一个合理的人,如果以公司高级人员的身份行事,会认为该等信息是公司的内幕消息。

“高级人员”的含义被广义的解释。它包括上市公司的董事、公司秘书和经理。一个人如果直接受命于董事会,并对上市公司的整体或大部分承担管理责任,则其可以被视为经理。

证监会的观点是最终应由高级人员对上市公司的信息披露义务承担合规责任。《证券及期货条例》要求每一名高级人员不时地采取一切合理方法,确保适当的保障措施存在,以防止上市公司违反法定的披露要求。如果一名高级人员因为蓄意、罔顾后果或疏忽而导致上市公司违规,未能作出应有的披露,该高级人员可须根据《证券及期货条例》承担个人责任。如果董事会作为一个整体未能建立或监督关键的内部控制程序以确保上市公司充分遵守法定披露要求,那么没有经常性参与该上市公司日常运作的非执行董事也可能会因此而承担责任。

什么是“内幕消息”?

根据《证券及期货条例》的定义,“内幕消息”就上市公司而言,是指与下列事项有关的具体信息:(a) 该上市公司,(b)该公司的股东或高级人员,或(c)该公司的上市证券或该等证券的衍生工具;以及,并非为惯常参与或可能参与该公司上市证券交易的人普遍所知,但一旦为其普遍所知,该等信息很可能对该公司上市证券的价格造成重大影响。

任何特定信息是否构成内幕消息,取决于该信息本身涵盖的事实和周边的环境。即使信息是不完整的,但能够使一个事宜或事件得到识别,并且该事宜或事件的性质能够被合乎逻辑地描述和理解,也可构成具体信息。这同样适用于尚处于初步谈判阶段的拟进行交易,除非该交易还只是一个含糊的希望或个人的愿景。
 
上市公司不应该理所当然地将媒体或分析报告报导了的任何信息视为普遍所知。上市公司应该考虑该等信息在何等广度上已经或将要在市场上传播,以及所传播的信息是否准确及完整。如果市场所知的信息尚未提供给散户投资者,或者是不完整或不准确的,该等信息不能被视为普遍所知。

上市公司应进一步评估该等信息是否可能对其上市证券的市场价格造成重大影响。该等评估将取决于各种因素,如上市公司的性质和规模、信息的主题和市场条件等。

披露的方式和时间
 
上市公司必须立即采取一切必要步骤以公司公告的形式,通过香港的证券交易电子公告系统披露任何内幕消息——除非该信息属于《证券及期货条例》第307D条下的“安全港”规则保护范畴之内。作出全面披露前,上市公司应确保信息严格保密。如果披露前不能维持保密状态,上市公司应该考虑申请暂停其证券交易,直到完成披露为止。

 
发布公告时几个实用的注意事项

在“常见问题解答”中,证监会明确指出,上市公司不应以“自愿性公告”为标题发布内幕消息披露公告,而应采用能准确反映有关信息实质内容的有意义的标题。否则,上市公司将有违反《证券及期货条例》的风险。

公告中披露的内幕消息应该是基于对事实的描述、清楚并且以一种中立和客观的方式加以表述。关键信息应清晰可见,并以一种容易理解的方式表达。上市公司已知的充分量化信息也应当包含在披露之中,以确保披露公告没有错误或误导性。

 
陆志明为美国温斯顿律师事务所香港办事处合伙人及亚洲业务主席。他的联系电话 +852 2292 2222 ;电子邮件 sluk@winston.com

邓杰名为美国温斯顿律师事务所香港办事处律师。她的联系电话 +852 2292 2218 ;电子邮件 ftang@winston.com

Monday, April 1, 2013

Private equity in Hong Kong: market and regulatory overview - PLC Which Lawyer


PLC Which Lawyer


Private equity in Hong Kong: market and regulatory overview





A Q&A guide to private equity law in Hong Kong.

This Q&A is part of the PLC multi-jurisdictional guide to private equity. It gives a structured overview of the key practical issues including, the level of activity and recent trends in the market; investment incentives for institutional and private investors; the mechanics involved in establishing a private equity fund; equity and debt finance issues in a private equity transaction; issues surrounding buyouts and the relationship between the portfolio company's managers and the private equity funds; management incentives; and exit routes from investments. Details on national private equity and venture capital associations are also included.

To compare answers across multiple jurisdictions, visit the Private Equity Country Q&A tool.  The Q&A is part of the PLC multi-jurisdictional guide to private equity law. For a full list of jurisdictional Q&As visit www.practicallaw.com/privateequity-mjg.

Simon Luk and Mark Jacobsen, Winston & Strawn

Contents


























Market overview


1. How do private equity funds typically obtain their funding?

Many private equity (PE) funds with a presence in Hong Kong are established in offshore tax havens such as the Cayman Islands, but managed in Hong Kong. Funding of PE funds generally comes from high net-worth individuals, pension funds, insurance companies, financial institutions, sovereign wealth funds (SWF) and companies that have surplus money to make investments. Financial institutions and SWFs can compete directly with PE funds for investment opportunities or invest directly in PE funds.

 

2. What are the current major trends in the private equity market?

Hong Kong is a relatively small market. However, Hong Kong traditionally serves as a base of operations and gateway to larger markets in Northeast Asia (excluding Japan), such as mainland China, South Korea and Taiwan. Therefore, the PE focus in Hong Kong is mostly on investing in those markets or supporting businesses that originate from those markets. More recently, the focus has been almost exclusively on China, as other markets once serviced out of Hong Kong have become more localised (such as South Korea) or reoriented towards Singapore (such as the Philippines and Vietnam). Therefore, discussion of PE investments in Hong Kong in this article focuses on PE investments in mainland China.

Inbound mainland China PE investments have slowed, starting in the second half of 2012 and continuing into 2013. PE investors' primary concern is receiving a good return on investment at exit, which is usually through an IPO or a sale of the company or its assets to a strategic investor.

IPOs are usually the preferred form of exit for PE/VC-backed Chinese companies. However, a combination of the poor performance of the PRC domestic economy and accounting scandals of previously listed PRC-based companies resulted in a significant drop of IPOs of PE/VC-backed Chinese companies in 2012.

According to a Wall Street Journal report in January 2013, which cites relevant data from Dealogic, trade sales in China are not as active as in the more developed markets, with only an average of 15 per year over the past three years. This trend looks to continue, as:

·         Profit margins for PRC companies are very thin and almost every industry in China is dealing with oversupply or overinvestment issues (therefore inhibiting strategic investors' desire to expand through acquisitions of PRC businesses).

·         Many private PRC companies are still under the control of the founders, who tend to view the company as their own and are not as interested in being bought out.

As an alternative investment strategy, a number of US-listed companies based in China have been taken private by their founders in recent years. Successful transactions in 2011 included privatisations of China Fire (backed by Bain Capital), Chemspec (backed by Primavera), Funtalk China (backed by PAG Asia) and Harbin Electric (backed by Abax). However, late 2012 saw fewer of these deals, as prospects for potential relisting have diminished and the deployment of further funds by PE investors (providing liquidity for these privatisation deals) has slowed.

 

3. What has been the level of private equity activity in recent years?

Fundraising


Fundraising for PRC-focused funds tends to be divided into onshore and offshore funds. Onshore funds are domestic (in focus and legally) and denominated in RMB. Offshore funds have traditionally been US dollar denominated, but international sponsors started RMB denominated vehicles in 2009, under a "5% rule" introduced in a Shanghai pilot programme. If no more than 5% of the total capital of an RMB fund sponsored by foreign investors originates offshore, the fund is treated as a domestic fund and is therefore not subject to the foreign investment restrictions in China (5% rule). However, a proclamation issued by the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) in April 2012 states that an RMB fund with any foreign source remains "foreign". Compared with US dollar-denominated funds, RMB funds still dominate the current market.

Overall, PRC-focused PE fundraising plummeted in 2012 as compared to 2011.

Investment


While many PE funds tend to provide development or growth capital, buyout/rescue/vulture capital funds have begun to be more active lately. PE investors remain a small part of the overall funding mix in the PRC and have failed to provide a sufficient source of capital for most small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in China seeking capital. Manufacturing, agriculture, energy, health care, real estate and financial services are among the most popular target industries for PE investors.

Transactions


Notable PE-backed proposed going-private transactions disclosed in 2012 include:

·         7 Days Inn. Listed on NYSE and disclosed privatisation plan in September 2012 (backed by the Carlyle Group and Sequoia Capital).

·         Focus Media. Listed on NASDAQ and disclosed privatisation plan in August 2012 (backed by FountainVest Partners, the Carlyle Group and CITIC Capital).

·         ShangPharma Corp. Listed on NYSE and disclosed privatisation plan in July 2012 (backed by TPG).

Successful private investment in public equity (PIPE) deals involving Chinese companies increased in 2012, focused on the Chinese A-share market.

Exits


The number of PE-backed IPOs of PRC assets dropped significantly in 2012 (see Question 2).

China's secondary buyout market remains immature. A notable sale in 2012 is Actis Capital's sale of a majority stake in Beijing hot-pot chain Xiabu Xiabu to another US firm, General Atlantic, for an undisclosed amount. It had paid US$50 million for Xiabu Xiabu in 2008.

 


Reform


4. Are there any proposals for regulatory or other reforms affecting private equity in your jurisdiction?

A new Companies Ordinance (New Companies Ordinance) was passed in July 2012 and is expected to have effect from 2014. Some of the changes to the old Companies Ordinance are relevant to PE investors (for example, rules requiring directors to obtain members' authority to allot shares will be extended). In addition, directors will need shareholders' approval to grant rights to subscribe for or convert securities into shares such as warrants, share options or convertible bonds. However, the directors would not need to seek further approval for the allotment of shares on conversion or exercise of those rights. In addition, if a portfolio company is obliged to repurchase a PE investor's shares, any portfolio company wanting to buy back its shares will be able to repurchase shares out of the company's capital, subject to a solvency test (in addition to using the company's distributable profits) (New Companies Ordinance).

 

 

Tax incentive schemes


5. What tax incentive or other schemes exist to encourage investment in unlisted companies? At whom are the schemes directed? What conditions must be met?

Profits


Profits derived from carrying on a trade, profession or business in Hong Kong are subject to profits tax. However, only profits which arise in or are derived from Hong Kong (that is, Hong Kong-source profits) are subject to Hong Kong tax.

Dividends


There is no capital gains tax or withholding tax on dividends. Dividend income is chargeable to profits tax if it constitutes Hong Kong-source profits, unless it falls within section 26 of the Inland Revenue Ordinance (Cap. 112 of the Laws of Hong Kong) (IRO). Under this exemption, dividend income is not subject to profits tax if the corporation distributing the dividends is subject to profits tax on the dividend income.

 

 

Fund structuring


6. What legal structure(s) are most commonly used as a vehicle for private equity funds in your jurisdiction?

Most PE funds with a presence in Hong Kong are established in offshore tax havens and are managed or advised from Hong Kong. These PE funds are usually structured as limited liability partnerships in jurisdictions like the Cayman Island, with one general partner. Some PE funds established in Hong Kong also take the form of limited liability companies.

 

7. Are these structures taxed, tax exempt or tax transparent (flow through structures) for domestic and foreign investors?

Limited liability partnerships and companies


Limited liability partnerships and companies are generally not tax transparent in Hong Kong. The profits tax liability of a partnership is usually calculated by applying, to the total assessable profits of the partnership, either the:

·         Standard tax rate (in the case of a partnership of individuals).

·         Corporate tax rate (if the partnership is comprised only of corporations).

However, a partnership's tax liability is calculated by determining the tax liability of each partner individually, if either:

·         The partnership is comprised of both individual and corporate partners. Each partner is taxed individually as different profit tax rates apply to individuals and companies.

·         Some partners have losses to carry forward from previous assessment years.

Limited liability partnerships and companies are taxed in Hong Kong on any profits derived from carrying on a trade or business in Hong Kong, unless they qualify for one of the following profits tax-exempt investment schemes:

·         A collective investment scheme authorised by the Securities and Futures Commission (SFC). These generally consist of funds organised as unit trusts and mutual funds, investment-linked assurance schemes, pooled-retirement funds, MPF master trust schemes and MPF pooled investment funds.

·         An investment scheme where the Commissioner of Inland Revenue of Hong Kong is satisfied that the scheme both:

o    is a bona fide widely held investment scheme;

o    complies with the requirements of a supervisory authority within an acceptable regime.

This usually applies to investment schemes outside Hong Kong and recognised and regulated by their home jurisdiction. This includes money market, open end funds and other similarly regulated funds from one of a list of SFC recognised jurisdictions (for example, Australia, France, Germany, the US, UK or Taiwan).

Offshore funds


The Revenue (Profits Tax Exemption for Offshore Funds) Ordinance 2006 amended the IRO. This provides that an offshore fund is exempt from profits tax if all of the following apply:

·         The fund is non-resident in Hong Kong.

·         The fund's activities in Hong Kong are limited to "specified transaction" (such as transaction in securities, future contracts or foreign exchange contracts).

·         The transactions are carried out through or arranged by a specified person. Specified person means a corporation licensed or an authorised financial institution registered under the Securities and Futures Ordinance to carry on regulated activities.

Due to a technical interpretation of the law by the Inland Revenue Department, transactions relating to the offerings of private companies in Hong Kong (defined under the Companies Ordinance as having not more than 50 investors) are not exempted. Therefore, the exemption only exists for investments in the offerings of either listed or unlisted public companies.

 

8. What (if any) structures commonly used for private equity funds in other jurisdictions are regarded in your jurisdiction as not being tax transparent (in so far as they invest in companies in your jurisdiction)? What parallel domestic structures are typically used in these circumstances?

PE funds are commonly structured as limited liability partnerships in other tax havens, but they are not tax transparent in Hong Kong. Some PE funds established in Hong Kong take the form of limited liability companies.

 

 

Investment objectives


9. What are the most common investment objectives of private equity funds?

The most common objective of PE funds is to achieve capital appreciation on an exit from the portfolio companies. The average life cycle is from three to six years and the typical average rate of return sought is from 30% to 40% over the fund's life expectancy.

 

 

Fund regulation and licensing


10. Do a private equity fund's promoter, principals and manager require licences?

A PE fund's sponsors, principals and managers only need to be licensed if they carry on a regulated activity in Hong Kong. Regulated activities are defined as (Securities and Futures Ordinance (Cap. 571 of the Laws of Hong Kong) (SFO)):

·         Dealing in securities.

·         Dealing in future contracts.

·         Leveraged foreign exchange trading.

·         Advising on securities.

·         Advising on future contracts.

·         Advising on corporate finance.

·         Providing automated trading services.

·         Securities margin financing.

·         Asset management.

·         Providing credit rating service.

Among these, dealing in securities is most relevant to a PE sponsor or manager. However, the meaning of "securities" in this context does not include shares or debentures of a private company within the meaning of section 29 of the CO. Therefore, if a PE fund only invests in shares of these private companies in Hong Kong, the sponsor or the manager may not be required to obtain a licence from or register with the SFC. However, many sponsors and managers will continue to advise or deal in the shares of the portfolio companies after they are listed. Therefore, they usually obtain a licence from the SFC.

 

11. Are private equity funds regulated as investment companies or otherwise and, if so, what are the consequences? Are there any exemptions?

Regulation


The SFO regulates, among other things, the authorisation and operation of collective investment schemes, which is broadly defined and can include PE funds. If a PE fund qualifies as a collective investment scheme, it is subject to specific regulations including restrictions on public offerings.

It is an offence to issue an advertisement, invitation or document which is or contains an invitation to the Hong Kong public to invest in collective investment schemes, unless either (section 103, SFO):

·         The SFC has authorised it.

·         An exemption applies.

If the PE fund is structured as a limited liability company, any prospectus, notice, circular, brochure, advertisement or other documents which offers or invites offers to subscribe for shares in the company must generally comply with the SFO's content and registration requirements (CO).

Exemptions


Professional investor exemption. Section 103 of the SFO provides exemptions from the content and registration requirements for offers made only to professional investors. The term "professional investors" is broadly defined in the SFO and the Securities and Futures (Professional Investor) Rules to include:

·         A recognised exchange company or recognised clearing house.

·         An intermediary or other entity providing investment services and regulated under the laws of any place outside Hong Kong.

·         An authorised financial institution or any bank which is not an authorised financial institution but is regulated under the law of any place outside Hong Kong.

·         An insurer authorised under the Insurance Companies Ordinance (Cap. 41 of the Laws of Hong Kong) or any other person carrying on insurance business and regulated under the law of any place outside Hong Kong.

·         An authorised collective investment scheme under the SFO, or any similar overseas collective investment scheme regulated and permitted under the law of that foreign jurisdiction.

·         A trust company with total assets worth at least HK$40 million.

·         An individual, alone or with any of his associates on a joint account, with a portfolio worth at least HK$8 million.

·         A corporation or partnership with either a portfolio worth at least HK$8 million or total assets worth at least HK$40 million.

Offerings in Hong Kong are often co-ordinated to comply with the US laws on public offerings (including sophisticated and institutional investor definitions), as frequently there are US resident investors.

Private placement exemption. There is no statutory private placement exemption. However, if a PE fund is structured as a general partnership or a private company under the CO, an offer to 50 persons or fewer is not deemed to be a public offer of securities. Therefore, this type of "private placement" can be exempted from the requirement to issue a prospectus.

This exemption can be used in conjunction with the professional investor exemption. Therefore, an offer to 50 persons or fewer who are not professional investors in conjunction with an offer to an unlimited number of professional investors does not constitute a public offer.

A fund aiming to raise capital in Hong Kong should comply with the following general guidelines:

·         The offering should not be publicly advertised or publicised.

·         The offer should be made to fewer than 50 non-professional investors.

·         Each offering document should be serial numbered by the fund sponsor and contain a prescribed warning statement (as outlined in the CO) on its cover.

·         All recipients must be warned that the offering is not made to the public, is restrictive and that the offer document should not be passed on to anyone.

 

12. Are there any restrictions on investors in private equity funds?

There are no direct restrictions on investors in PE funds. However, there may be restrictions on soliciting investors for capital, which limits marketing (see Question 11, Regulation). To avoid this restriction, PE funds usually require potential investors to be high net-worth individuals, pension funds, insurance companies or other financial institutions.

 

13. Are there any statutory or other limits on maximum or minimum investment periods, amounts or transfers of investments in private equity funds?

There are no statutory limits on maximum or minimum investment periods, amounts or transfers of investment in PE funds. There may be contractual restrictions relating to these matters and detailed terms are usually set out in the limited liability partnership agreement.

 

 

Investor protection


14. How is the relationship between the investor and the fund governed? What protections do investors in the fund typically seek?

For many US dollar denominated offshore funds, the relationship between the investors (limited partners) (LPs), the general partner (GP) and the fund is mainly governed by a limited liability partnership agreement (LPA). The LPA specifies the rights and obligations of the parties and typically provides the following mechanisms to protect LPs' interests:

·         Restrictions on the maximum amount of investment that the fund can invest in a single portfolio company.

·         LPs' rights to appoint members to the investment advisory committee.

·         LPs' rights to remove the general partner under certain specified conditions.

·         LPs' rights to access the fund's books and records.

·         LPs' rights to terminate the GP's ability to call the remaining capital commitments to make new investments if certain events occur (for example, key individuals have left the GP or the fund manager).

·         Restrictions on the transfer of the general partner's interest in the fund.

 

 

Interests in portfolio companies


15. What forms of equity and debt interest are commonly taken by a private equity fund in a portfolio company? What are the relative advantages and disadvantages of each? Are there any restrictions on the issue or transfer of shares by law?

Common forms


The PE's investments commonly take the form of preferred shares and/or equity-linked debts, such as convertible bonds. In buyouts, part of the investment may also take the form of loan notes.

Advantages and disadvantages


The investment agreement governing PE investments usually imposes restrictions on the transfer of shares. Therefore, conversion rights afforded by equity-linked debts give a PE investor flexibility in deciding how to maximise its investment on the basis of the investee company's performance. In addition, as all equity securities rank behind all debt in liquidation, debt is preferable to a PE investor.

Restrictions


If the investee is a Hong Kong company incorporated under the CO, the company directors can only issue and allot new shares after obtaining shareholders' approval in general shareholder meetings. However, this does not apply to allotments of shares to the founder members or allotments by pro-rata offers to the existing shareholders.

If the investee is a private company in Hong Kong, the articles of association must restrict the transfer of its shares, so that the company retains private status. Another common restriction for PE investments is shareholders' pre-emption rights.

 

 

Buyouts


16. Is it common for buyouts of private companies to take place by auction? If so, which legislation and rules apply?

Buyouts of private companies by auction are not common. There are no rules or legislation directly governing the sale of private companies by auction.

 

17. Are buyouts of listed companies (public-to-private transactions) common? If so, which legislation and rules apply?

Buyouts of listed companies sometimes occur when the PE investors provide financing to founders or managers to buy the listed companies and privatise them. These transactions are governed by the:

·         CO.

·         Codes on Takeovers and Mergers and Share Repurchases (Takeovers Code).

·         Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on the Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (Listing Rules), if the company is listed in Hong Kong.

The law governing the takeover of public companies in Hong Kong is very complex and strictly enforced. Even internal discussions relating to these activities must be regulated and carefully considered.

Principal documentation


18. What are the principal documents produced in a buyout?

The principal documents produced in a buyout are the:

·         Sale and purchase agreement. This sets out the terms relating to the share acquisition between the selling shareholders and the acquisition company.

·         Subscription and shareholder agreement (investment agreement). This sets out the terms relating to the subscription of shares in the newly incorporated company and regulates ongoing operational matters of the company post-buyout. A revised and restated memorandum and articles of association is generally prepared alongside the investment agreement.

If a buyout is partially financed by the debt providers, facilities/loan agreements, security documents and inter-creditor agreements may also be required.

Buyer protection


19. What forms of contractual buyer protection do private equity funds commonly request from sellers and/or management? Are these contractual protections different for buyouts of listed companies (public-to-private transactions)?

Representations and warranties


PE investors usually require representations and warranties from the seller, including the:

·         Seller's title to shares and capacity/authority to complete the transaction.

·         Investee company's title to its assets and the assets' condition.

·         Proper preparation of accounting records and statutory accounts of the investee company.

·         Investee company's material contracts.

·         Investee company's employees.

·         Investee company's compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

·         Investee company's litigation matters and potential risks.

In the context of a management buyout (MBO), the seller usually insists that the warranties are given "so far as the seller is aware" and that the knowledge of the management is imputed to the purchaser. This is so that the purchaser cannot bring a claim relating to matters that the management knew about before completion. The PE investor may also ask the management to give warranties in the investment agreement both:

·         Regarding the management's capacity to enter into the transaction (for example, that there is no breach of any existing agreement to which the management is a party).

·         That the management has no knowledge that anything outside the seller's disclosure letter should be disclosed.

Covenants


The investment agreement commonly includes restrictive covenants from the management in favour of the PE investor.

Indemnities and guarantees


PE investors require indemnities for any loss arising from a breach of warranties by the seller or management, in addition to damages for breach of warranty. If the seller is a special purpose vehicle, indemnities and/or guarantees are also required from its parent company with sufficient funds to honour its indemnity obligation.

Tax indemnities


PE investors usually require tax indemnities to protect the value of their investment against any tax liabilities which have not been provided for in the investee company's accounts.

Public-to-private transactions


In addition to the standard buyer protection provisions (see above), transactions with public companies often include provisions outlining transactional deal-breakers under the Takeovers Code and the Listing Rules. These include lack of shareholder approval, regulatory compliance and breach of covenants on the proper disclosure and handling of the takeover by the seller or company to be purchased. There may also be a material adverse change/effect clause, which provides a catch-all for various market, investor or insider events that may happen to a public company during the course of a transaction.

 

20. What non-contractual duties do the portfolio company managers owe and to whom?

The main non-contractual duties owed by managers of a portfolio company include:

·         A duty to maintain confidentially with regard to information relating to the company and its business.

·         Fiduciary duties if they are directors.

·         Duties of care and skill.

In addition, the Companies Ordinance imposes numerous statutory duties on directors (for example, to keep proper books and accounts, and properly file documents and returns at the Companies Registry). These duties are owed to the company and can generally be enforced by the company.

Directors of public companies are subject to additional statutory duties under the SFO, the Listing Rules and the Takeovers Code (during the course of a takeover). These include prohibitions on insider trading and duties relating to fair dealing with minority shareholders and takeover offers.

 

21. What terms of employment are typically imposed on management by the private equity investor in an MBO?

A PE investor usually imposes:

·         Non-compete covenants.

·         Non-solicitation covenants.

·         Non-disclosure covenants.

·         Compulsory sale of shares on departure.

 

22. What measures are commonly used to give a private equity fund a level of management control over the activities of the portfolio company? Are such protections more likely to be given in the shareholders' agreement or company governance documents?

To have some level of management control, PE investors usually require various special rights, such as:

·         A right to appoint director(s) on the board of the investee company.

·         A right to appoint the chief financial officer or financial manager of the investee company.

·         Veto rights over major corporate actions of the investee company.

·         Information and inspection rights.

These rights are usually found in both the investment agreement and the company's memorandum and articles of association, to give the public notice of these rights.

 

 

Debt financing


23. What percentage of finance is typically provided by debt and what form does that debt financing usually take?

The choice of debt as a financing capital depends, to a certain extent, on the relative cost of capital and the willingness of the PE investor to take equity versus debt. For venture capital or development capital investments, PE investors traditionally only seek equity stakes or equity linked instruments, due to the potential for appreciation in equity on exit.

However, for buyouts, debt (often in the form of notes) is usually used in combination with equity. Senior debt (including term facilities and revolving credit facilities) and junior debt (that is, mezzanine debts or high yield bonds) may constitute part of the financing required for buyout.

Lender protection


24. What forms of protection do debt providers typically use to protect their investments?

Security


The security structure usually consists of the borrower (typically the investee group company that is closest to the core assets of the business) granting a charge over its assets. The remaining investee group companies guarantee the borrower's obligations supported by charges over the assets of those companies, including the shares of their subsidiaries.

Contractual and structural mechanisms


Positive and negative undertakings. Undertakings aim to ensure that business is maintained and operated lawfully within certain agreed parameters, to prevent any leakage or diminution of the company's value that may be prejudicial to the position of debt providers.

Financial covenants. Financial covenants both:

·         Enable debt providers to monitor the financial strength of the borrower and the borrower group.

·         In the case of a breach of covenant, give debt providers an ability to accelerate the debt.

Subordination. Subordination is commonly used where the investee company has existing inter-company indebtedness or acquired shareholders' loans.

Financial assistance


25. Are there rules preventing a company from giving financial assistance for the purpose of assisting a purchase of shares in the company? If so, how does this affect the ability of a target company in a buyout to give security to lenders? Are there exemptions and, if so, which are most commonly used in the context of private equity transactions?

Rules


It is generally not lawful for a Hong Kong company or any of its subsidiaries to (CO):

·         Give financial assistance to a person acquiring the company's shares, whether it is given before or at the time of the acquisition, directly or indirectly.

·         Reduce or discharge any liability incurred for the purpose of acquiring the company's shares.

Financial assistance is statutorily defined as:

·         A gift.

·         A guarantee, security, indemnity, release or waiver.

·         A loan, novation or assignment of a loan.

·         Any other financial assistance resulting in the reduction of the company's net assets to a material extent.

If a target company gives a security to lenders providing debt finance to the purchaser in a buyout, this may constitute unlawful prohibited financial assistance unless an exemption applies.

Exemptions


There are specific exempted transactions that do not fall within the general prohibition. The prohibition is even more relaxed for unlisted companies, which can give financial assistance for the acquisition of its shares (or, if it is a subsidiary of an unlisted company, its holding company's shares) if the:

·         Assistance does not reduce the company's net assets or, if it does, the assistance is provided out of distributable profits.

·         Board makes a statutory statement confirming that, among other things, the company is and will remain solvent.

·         Company's shareholders approved the financial assistance by special resolution within 30 days of the board making the statutory statement. If the resolution is in the form of unanimous written resolution, a copy of the statement must be supplied to each member.

The directors' statement must be delivered to the Registrar of Companies together with a copy of the special resolution (if it is required) within 15 days of passing the resolution. The financial assistance must:

·         Not be given until the 29th day after the last relevant special resolution was passed (unless every member of the company voted for the resolution).

·         Be given within three months from the date on which the majority of the directors proposed to give the assistance made in their statement.

 

Insolvent liquidation


26. What is the order of priority on insolvent liquidation?

Secured creditors can pay themselves out of their security. They rank as unsecured creditors for any balance remaining unpaid. The company's assets are generally paid in the following order:

·         Liquidation costs.

·         Preferential creditors. These are divided into four categories with the following order of priority

o    employees;

o    government;

o    small depositors of licensed banks; and

o    insurers.

·         Floating charge holders.

·         Unsecured creditors.

·         Shareholders.

Equity appreciation


27. Can a debt holder achieve equity appreciation through conversion features such as rights, warrants or options?

Receiving appreciation through conversion features is not prohibited under Hong Kong law. However, the company must ensure that any equity converted from the convertible securities does not exceed the company's authorised share capital without shareholder approval.

 

 

Portfolio company management


28. What management incentives are most commonly used to encourage portfolio company management to produce healthy income returns and facilitate a successful exit from a private equity transaction?


 

29. Are any tax reliefs or incentives available to portfolio company managers investing in their company?

There are no specific tax reliefs or incentives aimed at encouraging portfolio company managers to invest in their company.

 

30. Are there any restrictions on dividends, interest payments and other payments by a portfolio company to its investors?

The basic principles governing all payments by a company to its members are:

·         A company's distributions must not exceed its realised profits.

·         Contributed share capital, including share premiums and capital redemption reserve should be returned to the members only on the winding-up of the company.

 

 

Exit strategies


31. What forms of exit are typically used to realise a private equity fund's investment in a successful company? What are the relative advantages and disadvantages of each?

Forms of exit


The most common forms of exit strategy are:

·         Initial public offering (IPO).

·         Trade sale.

·         Secondary buyout.

Advantages and disadvantages


IPO. An IPO may help a PE investor to obtain a higher valuation for its business than a trade sale or a secondary buyout. However, a successful IPO depends on the capital market conditions. In addition, listing rules of that jurisdiction or the underwriting agreement may impose lock-up periods on the shares owned by the PE investor, preventing a quick exit.

Trade sale. A major incentive for the purchaser in a trade sale is to achieve business synergies. Therefore, the purchaser may be willing to pay a premium to acquire the shares from the PE investors. Trade sales are less dependent on capital market conditions and can provide a more predictable sale price.

Secondary buyout. Secondary buyouts can provide a PE investor with access to liquidity and may be quicker when compared to an IPO or a trade sale.

 

32. What forms of exit are typically used to end the private equity fund's investment in an unsuccessful/distressed company? What are the relative advantages and disadvantages of each?

Forms of exit


The common forms of exit for unsuccessful investment are repurchase or redemption. The investor exercises its mandatory repurchase rights and requires the investee company or its majority shareholder to repurchase or redeem the shares owned by the PE investor after either:

·         A certain time period has elapsed following the investments.

·         The portfolio company is voluntarily wound up.

Advantages and disadvantages


For a mandatory repurchase, the PE investor agreement specifies the buyback price or the formula for calculating the price. The PE investor can get some money back if the investee company or its majority shareholder obliged to repurchase is solvent. If the investee company or its majority shareholder redeems or repurchases, there may be restrictions on the company's ability to repurchase its own shares (provided in the Companies Ordinance or the company's constitutional documents).

For voluntary winding-up, repurchase or redemption are the last resort. As equity holders, the PE investor ranks behind the company's creditors in priority and may face a write-off on its entire investment.

 

 

Private equity/venture capital associations


Hong Kong Venture Capital and Private Equity Association (HKVCA)



Status. The HKVCA is a non-governmental organisation.

Membership. HKVCA membership is open to both corporations and consultancy firms. There are two categories of membership within HKVCA: full membership and associate membership. Full membership includes institutions that directly invest in the venture capital and private equity. Associate membership includes institutions or individuals that are directly or indirectly associated with venture capital and private equity, including financial institutions, law firms, accounting firms or consultancy firms.

Principal activities. HKVCA members have monthly meetings and various courses on private equity investments.

Published guidelines. There are no guidelines published by the HKVCA.

Information sources. HKVCA's website: www.hkvca.com.hk/hkvcpea/front.php.





 

Online resources


Inland Revenue Department



Description. Hong Kong IRD guide to profits tax exemption for offshore funds.





 

Contributor profiles


Simon Luk, Chairman of Asian Practice and Partner


Winston & Strawn

T +852 2292 2000
F +852 2292 2200
E asiabusdev@winston.com
W www.winston.com

Professional qualifications. District of Columbia, Attorney; Hong Kong, Attorney; New York, Attorney

Areas of practice. Automotive and transportation industry; corporate lending; capital markets: debt investment and trading; project finance; international labour and employee relations; private equity LBOs/mergers, acquisitions, divestitures; private equity funds; venture capital/growth equity/emerging companies; PIPE transactions; corporate governance; mergers and acquisitions; securities offerings; foreign direct investment; joint venture.

Non-professional qualifications. Member of the Chinese General Chamber of Commerce.

Recent transactions

·         Advising a private offshore fund in its negotiation and entering into of a framework agreement with a PRC real estate company for the co-operation among the parties in the potential development of an outlet mall project in Shanghai by the client and the development of a hotel and other commercial establishments by the PRC company.

·         Representing Winner Medical Group Inc. (WWIN: NASDAQ), a leading medical disposable products manufacturer in China, in its going-private transaction, which closed on 11 December 2012.

·         Representing Duff & Phelps Securities, LLC, financial adviser to the special committee of the board of directors of Zhongpin, Inc. (HOGS: NASDAQ), in its going-private transaction.

Languages. English, Mandarin, Cantonese

Professional associations/memberships. Member of the New York State Bar Association and the Law Society of Hong Kong.

Publications. Round table: Mergers & Acquisitions, CorporateLiveWire.com, December 2012 (www.corporatelivewire.com/round-tables.html?id=mergers-acquisitions); Mergers and Acquisitions multi-jurisdictional guide 2012-13, PLC Which lawyer?, November 2012; Going private in the US, China Business Law Journal, August 2012.

Mark Jacobsen, Registered Foreign Lawyer


Winston & Strawn


T +852 2292 2000
F +852 2292 2200
E asiabusdev@winston.com
W www.winston.com

Professional qualifications. California, Attorney

Areas of practice. Public finance; private equity LBOs/mergers, acquisitions, divestitures; PIPE transactions; corporate governance; mergers and acquisitions; securities offerings; foreign direct investment; joint venture; commercial transactions; fund formation.

Non-professional qualifications. Company Secretary to The Mekong Club, a Hong Kong based non-profit charity that fights the business of human slavery.

Recent transactions

·         Representing Winner Medical Group Inc. (WWIN: NASDAQ), a leading medical disposable products manufacturer in China, in its going-private transaction which closed on 11 December 2012.

·         Advising on H.K. and U.S. IPOs, including S-1 and A-1 filings.

·         Assisting in S-3 shelf-registrations and PIPE transactions.

·         Advising on going private/going dark transactions.

·         Advising various reporting companies on 34 Act compliance issues, including SOX implementation.

·         Advising various funds on securities laws in the PRC in relation to fundraising exercises.
Languages. English; Mandarin